The influence of competing perceptual and motor priors in the context of the size-weight illusion

Gavin Buckingham, Melvyn A Goodale

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    Abstract

    When lifting objects of identical mass but different sizes, people perceive the smaller objects as weighing more than the larger ones (the 'size-weight' illusion, SWI). While individual's grip and load force rates are rapidly scaled to the objects' actual mass, the magnitude of the force used to lift these SWI-inducing objects is rarely discussed. Here, we show that participants continue to apply a greater loading force to a large SWI-inducing cube than to a small SWI cube, lift after lift. These differences in load force persisted long after initial errors in grip and load force rates had been corrected. Interestingly, participants who showed the largest illusion made the smallest errors in load force. This unexpected relationship suggests that the motor system is consistently biased toward the expectations of heaviness for a particular stimulus in a Bayesian fashion, and that this loading error is subsequently reduced by SWI perceptual errors in the opposite direction.
    Original languageEnglish
    Pages (from-to)283-8
    Number of pages6
    JournalExperimental Brain Research
    Volume205
    Issue number2
    DOIs
    Publication statusPublished - Aug 2010

    Fingerprint

    Weights and Measures
    Hand Strength

    Cite this

    Buckingham, Gavin ; Goodale, Melvyn A. / The influence of competing perceptual and motor priors in the context of the size-weight illusion. In: Experimental Brain Research. 2010 ; Vol. 205, No. 2. pp. 283-8.
    @article{c8d302ec8b0f462382d488e5081d170b,
    title = "The influence of competing perceptual and motor priors in the context of the size-weight illusion",
    abstract = "When lifting objects of identical mass but different sizes, people perceive the smaller objects as weighing more than the larger ones (the 'size-weight' illusion, SWI). While individual's grip and load force rates are rapidly scaled to the objects' actual mass, the magnitude of the force used to lift these SWI-inducing objects is rarely discussed. Here, we show that participants continue to apply a greater loading force to a large SWI-inducing cube than to a small SWI cube, lift after lift. These differences in load force persisted long after initial errors in grip and load force rates had been corrected. Interestingly, participants who showed the largest illusion made the smallest errors in load force. This unexpected relationship suggests that the motor system is consistently biased toward the expectations of heaviness for a particular stimulus in a Bayesian fashion, and that this loading error is subsequently reduced by SWI perceptual errors in the opposite direction.",
    author = "Gavin Buckingham and Goodale, {Melvyn A}",
    year = "2010",
    month = "8",
    doi = "10.1007/s00221-010-2353-9",
    language = "English",
    volume = "205",
    pages = "283--8",
    journal = "Experimental Brain Research",
    issn = "0014-4819",
    publisher = "Springer",
    number = "2",

    }

    The influence of competing perceptual and motor priors in the context of the size-weight illusion. / Buckingham, Gavin; Goodale, Melvyn A.

    In: Experimental Brain Research, Vol. 205, No. 2, 08.2010, p. 283-8.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    TY - JOUR

    T1 - The influence of competing perceptual and motor priors in the context of the size-weight illusion

    AU - Buckingham, Gavin

    AU - Goodale, Melvyn A

    PY - 2010/8

    Y1 - 2010/8

    N2 - When lifting objects of identical mass but different sizes, people perceive the smaller objects as weighing more than the larger ones (the 'size-weight' illusion, SWI). While individual's grip and load force rates are rapidly scaled to the objects' actual mass, the magnitude of the force used to lift these SWI-inducing objects is rarely discussed. Here, we show that participants continue to apply a greater loading force to a large SWI-inducing cube than to a small SWI cube, lift after lift. These differences in load force persisted long after initial errors in grip and load force rates had been corrected. Interestingly, participants who showed the largest illusion made the smallest errors in load force. This unexpected relationship suggests that the motor system is consistently biased toward the expectations of heaviness for a particular stimulus in a Bayesian fashion, and that this loading error is subsequently reduced by SWI perceptual errors in the opposite direction.

    AB - When lifting objects of identical mass but different sizes, people perceive the smaller objects as weighing more than the larger ones (the 'size-weight' illusion, SWI). While individual's grip and load force rates are rapidly scaled to the objects' actual mass, the magnitude of the force used to lift these SWI-inducing objects is rarely discussed. Here, we show that participants continue to apply a greater loading force to a large SWI-inducing cube than to a small SWI cube, lift after lift. These differences in load force persisted long after initial errors in grip and load force rates had been corrected. Interestingly, participants who showed the largest illusion made the smallest errors in load force. This unexpected relationship suggests that the motor system is consistently biased toward the expectations of heaviness for a particular stimulus in a Bayesian fashion, and that this loading error is subsequently reduced by SWI perceptual errors in the opposite direction.

    U2 - 10.1007/s00221-010-2353-9

    DO - 10.1007/s00221-010-2353-9

    M3 - Article

    VL - 205

    SP - 283

    EP - 288

    JO - Experimental Brain Research

    JF - Experimental Brain Research

    SN - 0014-4819

    IS - 2

    ER -