Teaching grandmothers how to suck eggs. Do shiftworkers need rules or guidelines?

A. Wedderburn

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    Abstract

    Four methods of transforming research into practice are reviewed: (1) summaries by academics for governments; (2) reviews in professional journals for shiftworking populations; (3) guidelines for shiftworkers by shiftwork researchers; and (4) international laws and recommendations. Examples are cited from a selection of these that appear to be in part defective, unbalanced, misleading, biased, idiosyncratic, or ignorant. It is concluded that until more careful controlled evaluations are carried out, experts should be cautious in providing advice to shiftworkers that is not demonstrably better than the advice they get from experienced 'grandmother' shiftworkers.

    Original languageEnglish
    Pages (from-to)239-246
    Number of pages8
    JournalErgonomics
    Volume36
    Issue number1-3
    Publication statusPublished - 1993

    Fingerprint

    scientific journal
    international law
    expert
    Teaching
    evaluation

    Cite this

    Wedderburn, A. / Teaching grandmothers how to suck eggs. Do shiftworkers need rules or guidelines?. In: Ergonomics. 1993 ; Vol. 36, No. 1-3. pp. 239-246.
    @article{e84d701cfe644a36a384a5736c806618,
    title = "Teaching grandmothers how to suck eggs. Do shiftworkers need rules or guidelines?",
    abstract = "Four methods of transforming research into practice are reviewed: (1) summaries by academics for governments; (2) reviews in professional journals for shiftworking populations; (3) guidelines for shiftworkers by shiftwork researchers; and (4) international laws and recommendations. Examples are cited from a selection of these that appear to be in part defective, unbalanced, misleading, biased, idiosyncratic, or ignorant. It is concluded that until more careful controlled evaluations are carried out, experts should be cautious in providing advice to shiftworkers that is not demonstrably better than the advice they get from experienced 'grandmother' shiftworkers.",
    author = "A. Wedderburn",
    year = "1993",
    language = "English",
    volume = "36",
    pages = "239--246",
    journal = "Ergonomics",
    issn = "0014-0139",
    publisher = "Taylor & Francis",
    number = "1-3",

    }

    Teaching grandmothers how to suck eggs. Do shiftworkers need rules or guidelines? / Wedderburn, A.

    In: Ergonomics, Vol. 36, No. 1-3, 1993, p. 239-246.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    TY - JOUR

    T1 - Teaching grandmothers how to suck eggs. Do shiftworkers need rules or guidelines?

    AU - Wedderburn, A.

    PY - 1993

    Y1 - 1993

    N2 - Four methods of transforming research into practice are reviewed: (1) summaries by academics for governments; (2) reviews in professional journals for shiftworking populations; (3) guidelines for shiftworkers by shiftwork researchers; and (4) international laws and recommendations. Examples are cited from a selection of these that appear to be in part defective, unbalanced, misleading, biased, idiosyncratic, or ignorant. It is concluded that until more careful controlled evaluations are carried out, experts should be cautious in providing advice to shiftworkers that is not demonstrably better than the advice they get from experienced 'grandmother' shiftworkers.

    AB - Four methods of transforming research into practice are reviewed: (1) summaries by academics for governments; (2) reviews in professional journals for shiftworking populations; (3) guidelines for shiftworkers by shiftwork researchers; and (4) international laws and recommendations. Examples are cited from a selection of these that appear to be in part defective, unbalanced, misleading, biased, idiosyncratic, or ignorant. It is concluded that until more careful controlled evaluations are carried out, experts should be cautious in providing advice to shiftworkers that is not demonstrably better than the advice they get from experienced 'grandmother' shiftworkers.

    M3 - Article

    VL - 36

    SP - 239

    EP - 246

    JO - Ergonomics

    JF - Ergonomics

    SN - 0014-0139

    IS - 1-3

    ER -