Rates of Window Glass Replacement in Historic Buildings: A Bespoke Computational Analysis Approach for Scottish Planning Authorities Listed Building Consent Data

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Since the Middle Ages advances in manufacture and chemical processes have improved standards of window glass production. This can be identified through decreasing levels of visible imperfections in window glass made ostensibly, prior to the 1950s. The importance of retaining historic window glass cannot be understated with the inherently imbued cultural, aesthetic and historical value. Windows are the element of historic buildings most at risk from replacement by newer equivalents. In order to quantify the extent to which historic windows are replaced,we rely on data published by local authorities.However,this data can be difficult to access and analyse due to the disparate and complex nature of local authority websites.Here we introduce a bespoke computer programme, written and developed specifically to extract planning data with its disparate and multifaceted parameters. The programme enables trends in window replacement over time to be discerned. Within local authorities,both general planning and listed building applications related to windows have a high approval rate. Listing appears not to offer significant protection for windows. Despite the promotional efforts of national and international heritage organisations in favour of repairing and upgrading existing windows,in practice,these appear to have little effect at local level.
Original languageEnglish
JournalHistoric Environment: Policy and Practice
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 6 Jan 2020

Fingerprint

historic building
replacement
glass
Middle Ages
esthetics
chemical process
software
planning
rate
analysis
local authority

Cite this

@article{a6475206ea0547d48b3b285dbfa1d1dc,
title = "Rates of Window Glass Replacement in Historic Buildings: A Bespoke Computational Analysis Approach for Scottish Planning Authorities Listed Building Consent Data",
abstract = "Since the Middle Ages advances in manufacture and chemical processes have improved standards of window glass production. This can be identified through decreasing levels of visible imperfections in window glass made ostensibly, prior to the 1950s. The importance of retaining historic window glass cannot be understated with the inherently imbued cultural, aesthetic and historical value. Windows are the element of historic buildings most at risk from replacement by newer equivalents. In order to quantify the extent to which historic windows are replaced,we rely on data published by local authorities.However,this data can be difficult to access and analyse due to the disparate and complex nature of local authority websites.Here we introduce a bespoke computer programme, written and developed specifically to extract planning data with its disparate and multifaceted parameters. The programme enables trends in window replacement over time to be discerned. Within local authorities,both general planning and listed building applications related to windows have a high approval rate. Listing appears not to offer significant protection for windows. Despite the promotional efforts of national and international heritage organisations in favour of repairing and upgrading existing windows,in practice,these appear to have little effect at local level.",
author = "Caitlyn Phipps and Forster, {Alan Mark} and Kennedy, {Craig J.}",
year = "2020",
month = "1",
day = "6",
doi = "10.1080/17567505.2020.1709282",
language = "English",
journal = "Historic Environment: Policy and Practice",
issn = "1756-7505",
publisher = "Maney Publishing",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Rates of Window Glass Replacement in Historic Buildings: A Bespoke Computational Analysis Approach for Scottish Planning Authorities Listed Building Consent Data

AU - Phipps, Caitlyn

AU - Forster, Alan Mark

AU - Kennedy, Craig J.

PY - 2020/1/6

Y1 - 2020/1/6

N2 - Since the Middle Ages advances in manufacture and chemical processes have improved standards of window glass production. This can be identified through decreasing levels of visible imperfections in window glass made ostensibly, prior to the 1950s. The importance of retaining historic window glass cannot be understated with the inherently imbued cultural, aesthetic and historical value. Windows are the element of historic buildings most at risk from replacement by newer equivalents. In order to quantify the extent to which historic windows are replaced,we rely on data published by local authorities.However,this data can be difficult to access and analyse due to the disparate and complex nature of local authority websites.Here we introduce a bespoke computer programme, written and developed specifically to extract planning data with its disparate and multifaceted parameters. The programme enables trends in window replacement over time to be discerned. Within local authorities,both general planning and listed building applications related to windows have a high approval rate. Listing appears not to offer significant protection for windows. Despite the promotional efforts of national and international heritage organisations in favour of repairing and upgrading existing windows,in practice,these appear to have little effect at local level.

AB - Since the Middle Ages advances in manufacture and chemical processes have improved standards of window glass production. This can be identified through decreasing levels of visible imperfections in window glass made ostensibly, prior to the 1950s. The importance of retaining historic window glass cannot be understated with the inherently imbued cultural, aesthetic and historical value. Windows are the element of historic buildings most at risk from replacement by newer equivalents. In order to quantify the extent to which historic windows are replaced,we rely on data published by local authorities.However,this data can be difficult to access and analyse due to the disparate and complex nature of local authority websites.Here we introduce a bespoke computer programme, written and developed specifically to extract planning data with its disparate and multifaceted parameters. The programme enables trends in window replacement over time to be discerned. Within local authorities,both general planning and listed building applications related to windows have a high approval rate. Listing appears not to offer significant protection for windows. Despite the promotional efforts of national and international heritage organisations in favour of repairing and upgrading existing windows,in practice,these appear to have little effect at local level.

U2 - 10.1080/17567505.2020.1709282

DO - 10.1080/17567505.2020.1709282

M3 - Article

JO - Historic Environment: Policy and Practice

JF - Historic Environment: Policy and Practice

SN - 1756-7505

ER -