Impact of WAG design on calcite scaling risk in coupled CO2-EOR and storage projects in carbonate reservoirs

Hydra Rodrigues, Eric Mackay, Daniel Arnold

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference contribution

Abstract

WAG (Water-Alternating-Gas) schemes have been applied in Brazilian carbonate reservoirs aiming to minimize residual oil saturation and gas flaring by recycling CO2 naturally being produced alongside hydrocarbon gas. However, applying WAG injection in highly reactive and heterogeneous carbonate rocks can potentially create severe scaling problems. This work develops a reactive transport simulation-based workflow to evaluate the impact of key WAG design parameters on oil recovery, scale deposition risk and CO2 storage to support multi-objective decision-making. Compositional simulations of WAG scenarios were performed as part of a sensitivity study followed by statistical analysis in order to quantify to what extent the outcomes of interest are sensitive to variations on four WAG design parameters: WAG ratio, CO2 concentration in the injection gas stream, injection rate and solvent slug-size. We established an Equation-of-State (EoS) using PVT data, a representative geochemical model and well constrains designed to control production of injected fluids. Scale risk was assessed by calcite changes around the wells, precipitation in well tubing and surface facilities, and water breakthrough. Results of this study showed that values of calcite rate constant (Ksp) and reactive surface area (A0) assigned in numerical simulations can impact relative calcite changes in the reservoir. Using reactive surface areas from BET studies of crushed rocks can lead to prediction of unrealistic amounts of calcite dissolution. Cases with lower values of (Ksp×A0) appeared to be more numerically stable and more consistent with dissolution/precipitation rates of silicate minerals. Simulation results also suggested that calcite dissolution close to injection wells and precipitation in production wells and surface facilities become more severe as CO2 concentration in injection gas and WAG ratio increases. Based on the design variables and reservoir conditions studied, the most to least crucial factors affecting oil recovery were: CO2 concentration in the injection gas stream, injection rate, WAG ratio and solvent slug-size. From a storage perspective, the impact of the design variables had considerably more impact, with the most influential factor being again CO2 concentration in the injection gas stream, followed by WAG ratio, injection rate and solvent slug-size. Optimization study results suggested that low WAG ratio values combined with low to intermediate gas slug sizes could result in superior profitability and CO2 storage outcomes for this pilot. Ultimately, we demonstrate the importance of integrating multiphase miscible displacement with geochemical reactions while modeling complex CO2-EOR in carbonate reservoirs and address how key design parameters impact our desired outcomes, knowledge that promotes a more robust decision-making framework.

Original languageEnglish
Title of host publicationSPE Reservoir Simulation Conference 2019
PublisherSociety of Petroleum Engineers
ISBN (Electronic)9781613996348
Publication statusPublished - 10 Apr 2019
EventSPE Reservoir Simulation Conference 2019 - Galveston, United States
Duration: 10 Apr 201911 Apr 2019

Conference

ConferenceSPE Reservoir Simulation Conference 2019
Abbreviated titleRSC 2019
CountryUnited States
CityGalveston
Period10/04/1911/04/19

Fingerprint

Calcium Carbonate
Carbonates
Calcite
calcite
Gases
Scaling
Water
carbonate
gas
Injection
water
slug
Oils
Dissolution
Parameter Design
project
Design
Gas
dissolution
Decision making

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Geochemistry and Petrology
  • Modelling and Simulation

Cite this

Rodrigues, H., Mackay, E., & Arnold, D. (2019). Impact of WAG design on calcite scaling risk in coupled CO2-EOR and storage projects in carbonate reservoirs. In SPE Reservoir Simulation Conference 2019 [SPE-193882-MS] Society of Petroleum Engineers .
Rodrigues, Hydra ; Mackay, Eric ; Arnold, Daniel. / Impact of WAG design on calcite scaling risk in coupled CO2-EOR and storage projects in carbonate reservoirs. SPE Reservoir Simulation Conference 2019. Society of Petroleum Engineers , 2019.
@inproceedings{026c0e63f5074823b0e97cb563270dab,
title = "Impact of WAG design on calcite scaling risk in coupled CO2-EOR and storage projects in carbonate reservoirs",
abstract = "WAG (Water-Alternating-Gas) schemes have been applied in Brazilian carbonate reservoirs aiming to minimize residual oil saturation and gas flaring by recycling CO2 naturally being produced alongside hydrocarbon gas. However, applying WAG injection in highly reactive and heterogeneous carbonate rocks can potentially create severe scaling problems. This work develops a reactive transport simulation-based workflow to evaluate the impact of key WAG design parameters on oil recovery, scale deposition risk and CO2 storage to support multi-objective decision-making. Compositional simulations of WAG scenarios were performed as part of a sensitivity study followed by statistical analysis in order to quantify to what extent the outcomes of interest are sensitive to variations on four WAG design parameters: WAG ratio, CO2 concentration in the injection gas stream, injection rate and solvent slug-size. We established an Equation-of-State (EoS) using PVT data, a representative geochemical model and well constrains designed to control production of injected fluids. Scale risk was assessed by calcite changes around the wells, precipitation in well tubing and surface facilities, and water breakthrough. Results of this study showed that values of calcite rate constant (Ksp) and reactive surface area (A0) assigned in numerical simulations can impact relative calcite changes in the reservoir. Using reactive surface areas from BET studies of crushed rocks can lead to prediction of unrealistic amounts of calcite dissolution. Cases with lower values of (Ksp×A0) appeared to be more numerically stable and more consistent with dissolution/precipitation rates of silicate minerals. Simulation results also suggested that calcite dissolution close to injection wells and precipitation in production wells and surface facilities become more severe as CO2 concentration in injection gas and WAG ratio increases. Based on the design variables and reservoir conditions studied, the most to least crucial factors affecting oil recovery were: CO2 concentration in the injection gas stream, injection rate, WAG ratio and solvent slug-size. From a storage perspective, the impact of the design variables had considerably more impact, with the most influential factor being again CO2 concentration in the injection gas stream, followed by WAG ratio, injection rate and solvent slug-size. Optimization study results suggested that low WAG ratio values combined with low to intermediate gas slug sizes could result in superior profitability and CO2 storage outcomes for this pilot. Ultimately, we demonstrate the importance of integrating multiphase miscible displacement with geochemical reactions while modeling complex CO2-EOR in carbonate reservoirs and address how key design parameters impact our desired outcomes, knowledge that promotes a more robust decision-making framework.",
author = "Hydra Rodrigues and Eric Mackay and Daniel Arnold",
year = "2019",
month = "4",
day = "10",
language = "English",
booktitle = "SPE Reservoir Simulation Conference 2019",
publisher = "Society of Petroleum Engineers",
address = "United States",

}

Rodrigues, H, Mackay, E & Arnold, D 2019, Impact of WAG design on calcite scaling risk in coupled CO2-EOR and storage projects in carbonate reservoirs. in SPE Reservoir Simulation Conference 2019., SPE-193882-MS, Society of Petroleum Engineers , SPE Reservoir Simulation Conference 2019, Galveston, United States, 10/04/19.

Impact of WAG design on calcite scaling risk in coupled CO2-EOR and storage projects in carbonate reservoirs. / Rodrigues, Hydra; Mackay, Eric; Arnold, Daniel.

SPE Reservoir Simulation Conference 2019. Society of Petroleum Engineers , 2019. SPE-193882-MS.

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference contribution

TY - GEN

T1 - Impact of WAG design on calcite scaling risk in coupled CO2-EOR and storage projects in carbonate reservoirs

AU - Rodrigues, Hydra

AU - Mackay, Eric

AU - Arnold, Daniel

PY - 2019/4/10

Y1 - 2019/4/10

N2 - WAG (Water-Alternating-Gas) schemes have been applied in Brazilian carbonate reservoirs aiming to minimize residual oil saturation and gas flaring by recycling CO2 naturally being produced alongside hydrocarbon gas. However, applying WAG injection in highly reactive and heterogeneous carbonate rocks can potentially create severe scaling problems. This work develops a reactive transport simulation-based workflow to evaluate the impact of key WAG design parameters on oil recovery, scale deposition risk and CO2 storage to support multi-objective decision-making. Compositional simulations of WAG scenarios were performed as part of a sensitivity study followed by statistical analysis in order to quantify to what extent the outcomes of interest are sensitive to variations on four WAG design parameters: WAG ratio, CO2 concentration in the injection gas stream, injection rate and solvent slug-size. We established an Equation-of-State (EoS) using PVT data, a representative geochemical model and well constrains designed to control production of injected fluids. Scale risk was assessed by calcite changes around the wells, precipitation in well tubing and surface facilities, and water breakthrough. Results of this study showed that values of calcite rate constant (Ksp) and reactive surface area (A0) assigned in numerical simulations can impact relative calcite changes in the reservoir. Using reactive surface areas from BET studies of crushed rocks can lead to prediction of unrealistic amounts of calcite dissolution. Cases with lower values of (Ksp×A0) appeared to be more numerically stable and more consistent with dissolution/precipitation rates of silicate minerals. Simulation results also suggested that calcite dissolution close to injection wells and precipitation in production wells and surface facilities become more severe as CO2 concentration in injection gas and WAG ratio increases. Based on the design variables and reservoir conditions studied, the most to least crucial factors affecting oil recovery were: CO2 concentration in the injection gas stream, injection rate, WAG ratio and solvent slug-size. From a storage perspective, the impact of the design variables had considerably more impact, with the most influential factor being again CO2 concentration in the injection gas stream, followed by WAG ratio, injection rate and solvent slug-size. Optimization study results suggested that low WAG ratio values combined with low to intermediate gas slug sizes could result in superior profitability and CO2 storage outcomes for this pilot. Ultimately, we demonstrate the importance of integrating multiphase miscible displacement with geochemical reactions while modeling complex CO2-EOR in carbonate reservoirs and address how key design parameters impact our desired outcomes, knowledge that promotes a more robust decision-making framework.

AB - WAG (Water-Alternating-Gas) schemes have been applied in Brazilian carbonate reservoirs aiming to minimize residual oil saturation and gas flaring by recycling CO2 naturally being produced alongside hydrocarbon gas. However, applying WAG injection in highly reactive and heterogeneous carbonate rocks can potentially create severe scaling problems. This work develops a reactive transport simulation-based workflow to evaluate the impact of key WAG design parameters on oil recovery, scale deposition risk and CO2 storage to support multi-objective decision-making. Compositional simulations of WAG scenarios were performed as part of a sensitivity study followed by statistical analysis in order to quantify to what extent the outcomes of interest are sensitive to variations on four WAG design parameters: WAG ratio, CO2 concentration in the injection gas stream, injection rate and solvent slug-size. We established an Equation-of-State (EoS) using PVT data, a representative geochemical model and well constrains designed to control production of injected fluids. Scale risk was assessed by calcite changes around the wells, precipitation in well tubing and surface facilities, and water breakthrough. Results of this study showed that values of calcite rate constant (Ksp) and reactive surface area (A0) assigned in numerical simulations can impact relative calcite changes in the reservoir. Using reactive surface areas from BET studies of crushed rocks can lead to prediction of unrealistic amounts of calcite dissolution. Cases with lower values of (Ksp×A0) appeared to be more numerically stable and more consistent with dissolution/precipitation rates of silicate minerals. Simulation results also suggested that calcite dissolution close to injection wells and precipitation in production wells and surface facilities become more severe as CO2 concentration in injection gas and WAG ratio increases. Based on the design variables and reservoir conditions studied, the most to least crucial factors affecting oil recovery were: CO2 concentration in the injection gas stream, injection rate, WAG ratio and solvent slug-size. From a storage perspective, the impact of the design variables had considerably more impact, with the most influential factor being again CO2 concentration in the injection gas stream, followed by WAG ratio, injection rate and solvent slug-size. Optimization study results suggested that low WAG ratio values combined with low to intermediate gas slug sizes could result in superior profitability and CO2 storage outcomes for this pilot. Ultimately, we demonstrate the importance of integrating multiphase miscible displacement with geochemical reactions while modeling complex CO2-EOR in carbonate reservoirs and address how key design parameters impact our desired outcomes, knowledge that promotes a more robust decision-making framework.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85066629390&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Conference contribution

BT - SPE Reservoir Simulation Conference 2019

PB - Society of Petroleum Engineers

ER -

Rodrigues H, Mackay E, Arnold D. Impact of WAG design on calcite scaling risk in coupled CO2-EOR and storage projects in carbonate reservoirs. In SPE Reservoir Simulation Conference 2019. Society of Petroleum Engineers . 2019. SPE-193882-MS