How can we transition from lab to the real world with our HCI and HRI setups?

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference contribution

Abstract

In this position paper, we present the issues we and others have found when moving from the controlled lab space into the field. We therefore recommend some dos and don'ts for facing the challenge of transferring your research prototype from the lab to the real world. During this transfer, we often encounter crucial disconnects between our envisaged evaluation protocol and real life, often related to differing user expectations outside controlled experimental interactions. The redeployment of complex systems in unfamiliar (and often dissimilar) environments presents additional challenges.

In this paper, we present some example transitions in the fields of mobile HCI and HRI. Based on these experiences, we list the possible roadblocks that other researchers might encounter and provide guidelines and suggestions for dealing with frequently encountered issues. We hope that with this paper we can help stimulate the discussion on the pathway to undertaking scientifically reproducible evaluations in the wild.
Original languageEnglish
Title of host publicationThe 4th Workshop on Public Space Human-Robot Interaction
Subtitle of host publicationMobileHRI: Mobile human-robot interaction
Publication statusAccepted/In press - 19 Jun 2018
Event4th Workshop on Public Space Human-Robot Interaction 2018: MobileHRI: Mobile human-robot interaction - Barcelona, Spain
Duration: 3 Sep 20183 Sep 2018
http://homepages.inf.ed.ac.uk/rpetrick/events/pubrob/2018/

Workshop

Workshop4th Workshop on Public Space Human-Robot Interaction 2018
Abbreviated titlePubRob 2018
CountrySpain
CityBarcelona
Period3/09/183/09/18
Internet address

Fingerprint

Human computer interaction
Large scale systems
Network protocols

Keywords

  • Reliability
  • Design
  • Performance
  • Human computer interaction
  • human robot interaction

Cite this

Dondrup, C., Baillie, L., Lohan, K. S., & Broz, F. (Accepted/In press). How can we transition from lab to the real world with our HCI and HRI setups? In The 4th Workshop on Public Space Human-Robot Interaction: MobileHRI: Mobile human-robot interaction
Dondrup, Christian ; Baillie, Lynne ; Lohan, Katrin Solveig ; Broz, Frank. / How can we transition from lab to the real world with our HCI and HRI setups?. The 4th Workshop on Public Space Human-Robot Interaction: MobileHRI: Mobile human-robot interaction. 2018.
@inproceedings{160032e6e7c04a47879de8fff79e98e6,
title = "How can we transition from lab to the real world with our HCI and HRI setups?",
abstract = "In this position paper, we present the issues we and others have found when moving from the controlled lab space into the field. We therefore recommend some dos and don'ts for facing the challenge of transferring your research prototype from the lab to the real world. During this transfer, we often encounter crucial disconnects between our envisaged evaluation protocol and real life, often related to differing user expectations outside controlled experimental interactions. The redeployment of complex systems in unfamiliar (and often dissimilar) environments presents additional challenges.In this paper, we present some example transitions in the fields of mobile HCI and HRI. Based on these experiences, we list the possible roadblocks that other researchers might encounter and provide guidelines and suggestions for dealing with frequently encountered issues. We hope that with this paper we can help stimulate the discussion on the pathway to undertaking scientifically reproducible evaluations in the wild.",
keywords = "Reliability, Design, Performance, Human computer interaction, human robot interaction",
author = "Christian Dondrup and Lynne Baillie and Lohan, {Katrin Solveig} and Frank Broz",
year = "2018",
month = "6",
day = "19",
language = "English",
booktitle = "The 4th Workshop on Public Space Human-Robot Interaction",

}

Dondrup, C, Baillie, L, Lohan, KS & Broz, F 2018, How can we transition from lab to the real world with our HCI and HRI setups? in The 4th Workshop on Public Space Human-Robot Interaction: MobileHRI: Mobile human-robot interaction. 4th Workshop on Public Space Human-Robot Interaction 2018, Barcelona, Spain, 3/09/18.

How can we transition from lab to the real world with our HCI and HRI setups? / Dondrup, Christian; Baillie, Lynne; Lohan, Katrin Solveig; Broz, Frank.

The 4th Workshop on Public Space Human-Robot Interaction: MobileHRI: Mobile human-robot interaction. 2018.

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference contribution

TY - GEN

T1 - How can we transition from lab to the real world with our HCI and HRI setups?

AU - Dondrup, Christian

AU - Baillie, Lynne

AU - Lohan, Katrin Solveig

AU - Broz, Frank

PY - 2018/6/19

Y1 - 2018/6/19

N2 - In this position paper, we present the issues we and others have found when moving from the controlled lab space into the field. We therefore recommend some dos and don'ts for facing the challenge of transferring your research prototype from the lab to the real world. During this transfer, we often encounter crucial disconnects between our envisaged evaluation protocol and real life, often related to differing user expectations outside controlled experimental interactions. The redeployment of complex systems in unfamiliar (and often dissimilar) environments presents additional challenges.In this paper, we present some example transitions in the fields of mobile HCI and HRI. Based on these experiences, we list the possible roadblocks that other researchers might encounter and provide guidelines and suggestions for dealing with frequently encountered issues. We hope that with this paper we can help stimulate the discussion on the pathway to undertaking scientifically reproducible evaluations in the wild.

AB - In this position paper, we present the issues we and others have found when moving from the controlled lab space into the field. We therefore recommend some dos and don'ts for facing the challenge of transferring your research prototype from the lab to the real world. During this transfer, we often encounter crucial disconnects between our envisaged evaluation protocol and real life, often related to differing user expectations outside controlled experimental interactions. The redeployment of complex systems in unfamiliar (and often dissimilar) environments presents additional challenges.In this paper, we present some example transitions in the fields of mobile HCI and HRI. Based on these experiences, we list the possible roadblocks that other researchers might encounter and provide guidelines and suggestions for dealing with frequently encountered issues. We hope that with this paper we can help stimulate the discussion on the pathway to undertaking scientifically reproducible evaluations in the wild.

KW - Reliability

KW - Design

KW - Performance

KW - Human computer interaction

KW - human robot interaction

M3 - Conference contribution

BT - The 4th Workshop on Public Space Human-Robot Interaction

ER -

Dondrup C, Baillie L, Lohan KS, Broz F. How can we transition from lab to the real world with our HCI and HRI setups? In The 4th Workshop on Public Space Human-Robot Interaction: MobileHRI: Mobile human-robot interaction. 2018