Heuristics for type error discovery and recovery (revised revised)

Type error messages that are reported for incorrect functional programs can be difficult to understand. The reason for this is that most type inference algorithms proceed in a mechanical, syntax-directed way, and are unaware of inference techniques used by experts to explain type inconsistencies. We formulate type inference as a constraint problem, and analyze the collected constraints to improve the error messages (and, as a result, programming efficiency). A special data structure, the type graph, is used to detect global properties of a program, and furthermore enables us to uniformly describe a large collection of heuristics which embed expert knowledge in explaining type errors. Some of
these also suggest corrections to the programmer. Our work has been fully implemented and is used in practical situations, showing that it scales up well. We include a number of statistics from actual use of the compiler showing us the frequency with which heuristics are used, and the kind and number of suggested
corrections.