Epidemics with two levels of mixing

Frank Ball, Denis Mollison, Gianpaolo Scalia-Tomba

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

We consider epidemics with removal (SIR epidemics) in populations that mix at two levels: global and local. We develop a general modelling framework for such processes, which allows us to analyze the conditions under which a large outbreak is possible, the size of such outbreaks when they can occur and the implications for vaccination strategies, in each case comparing our results with the simpler homogeneous mixing case. More precisely, we consider models in which each infectious individual i has a global probability pG for infecting each other individual in the population and a local probability pL, typically much larger, of infecting each other individual among a set of neighbors script N (i). Our main concern is the case where the population is partitioned into local groups or households, but our approach also applies to cases where neighborhoods do not form a partition, for instance, to spatial models with a mixture of local (e.g., nearest-neighbor) and global contacts. We use a variety of theoretical approaches: a random graph framework for the initial exposition of the simple case where an individual's contacts are independent; branching process approximations for the general threshold result; and an embedding representation for rigorous results on the final size of outbreaks. From the applied viewpoint the key result is that, compared with the homogeneous mixing model in which individuals make contacts simply with probability pG, the local infectious contacts have an "amplification" effect. The basic reproductive ratio of the epidemic is increased from its individual-to-individual value RG in the absence of local infections to a group-to-group value R* = µRG, where µ is the mean size of an outbreak, started by a randomly chosen individual, in which only local infections count. Where the groups are large and the within-group epidemics are above threshold, this amplification can permit an outbreak in the whole population at very low levels of pG, for instance, for pG = O(1/Nn) in a population of N divided into groups of size n. The implication of these results for control strategies is that vaccination should be directed preferentially toward reducing µ; we discuss the conditions under which the equalizing strategy, aimed at leaving unvaccinated sets of neighbors of equal sizes, is optimal. We also discuss the estimation of our threshold parameter R* from data on epidemics among households.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)46-89
Number of pages44
JournalAnnals of Applied Probability
Volume7
Issue number1
Publication statusPublished - Feb 1997

Fingerprint

vaccination
amplification
SIR
modeling
household
infection
removal
parameter
effect

Keywords

  • Asymptotic distribution
  • Branching processes
  • Embedding
  • Epidemic
  • Estimation
  • Final outcome
  • Gontcharoff polynomials
  • Household
  • R 0
  • Random graphs
  • Reed-Frost
  • Threshold parameters
  • Vaccination

Cite this

Ball, F., Mollison, D., & Scalia-Tomba, G. (1997). Epidemics with two levels of mixing. Annals of Applied Probability, 7(1), 46-89.
Ball, Frank ; Mollison, Denis ; Scalia-Tomba, Gianpaolo. / Epidemics with two levels of mixing. In: Annals of Applied Probability. 1997 ; Vol. 7, No. 1. pp. 46-89.
@article{283f23746ee64ff8a86241c2d8044010,
title = "Epidemics with two levels of mixing",
abstract = "We consider epidemics with removal (SIR epidemics) in populations that mix at two levels: global and local. We develop a general modelling framework for such processes, which allows us to analyze the conditions under which a large outbreak is possible, the size of such outbreaks when they can occur and the implications for vaccination strategies, in each case comparing our results with the simpler homogeneous mixing case. More precisely, we consider models in which each infectious individual i has a global probability pG for infecting each other individual in the population and a local probability pL, typically much larger, of infecting each other individual among a set of neighbors script N (i). Our main concern is the case where the population is partitioned into local groups or households, but our approach also applies to cases where neighborhoods do not form a partition, for instance, to spatial models with a mixture of local (e.g., nearest-neighbor) and global contacts. We use a variety of theoretical approaches: a random graph framework for the initial exposition of the simple case where an individual's contacts are independent; branching process approximations for the general threshold result; and an embedding representation for rigorous results on the final size of outbreaks. From the applied viewpoint the key result is that, compared with the homogeneous mixing model in which individuals make contacts simply with probability pG, the local infectious contacts have an {"}amplification{"} effect. The basic reproductive ratio of the epidemic is increased from its individual-to-individual value RG in the absence of local infections to a group-to-group value R* = µRG, where µ is the mean size of an outbreak, started by a randomly chosen individual, in which only local infections count. Where the groups are large and the within-group epidemics are above threshold, this amplification can permit an outbreak in the whole population at very low levels of pG, for instance, for pG = O(1/Nn) in a population of N divided into groups of size n. The implication of these results for control strategies is that vaccination should be directed preferentially toward reducing µ; we discuss the conditions under which the equalizing strategy, aimed at leaving unvaccinated sets of neighbors of equal sizes, is optimal. We also discuss the estimation of our threshold parameter R* from data on epidemics among households.",
keywords = "Asymptotic distribution, Branching processes, Embedding, Epidemic, Estimation, Final outcome, Gontcharoff polynomials, Household, R 0, Random graphs, Reed-Frost, Threshold parameters, Vaccination",
author = "Frank Ball and Denis Mollison and Gianpaolo Scalia-Tomba",
year = "1997",
month = "2",
language = "English",
volume = "7",
pages = "46--89",
journal = "Annals of Applied Probability",
issn = "1050-5164",
publisher = "Institute of Mathematical Statistics",
number = "1",

}

Ball, F, Mollison, D & Scalia-Tomba, G 1997, 'Epidemics with two levels of mixing', Annals of Applied Probability, vol. 7, no. 1, pp. 46-89.

Epidemics with two levels of mixing. / Ball, Frank; Mollison, Denis; Scalia-Tomba, Gianpaolo.

In: Annals of Applied Probability, Vol. 7, No. 1, 02.1997, p. 46-89.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Epidemics with two levels of mixing

AU - Ball, Frank

AU - Mollison, Denis

AU - Scalia-Tomba, Gianpaolo

PY - 1997/2

Y1 - 1997/2

N2 - We consider epidemics with removal (SIR epidemics) in populations that mix at two levels: global and local. We develop a general modelling framework for such processes, which allows us to analyze the conditions under which a large outbreak is possible, the size of such outbreaks when they can occur and the implications for vaccination strategies, in each case comparing our results with the simpler homogeneous mixing case. More precisely, we consider models in which each infectious individual i has a global probability pG for infecting each other individual in the population and a local probability pL, typically much larger, of infecting each other individual among a set of neighbors script N (i). Our main concern is the case where the population is partitioned into local groups or households, but our approach also applies to cases where neighborhoods do not form a partition, for instance, to spatial models with a mixture of local (e.g., nearest-neighbor) and global contacts. We use a variety of theoretical approaches: a random graph framework for the initial exposition of the simple case where an individual's contacts are independent; branching process approximations for the general threshold result; and an embedding representation for rigorous results on the final size of outbreaks. From the applied viewpoint the key result is that, compared with the homogeneous mixing model in which individuals make contacts simply with probability pG, the local infectious contacts have an "amplification" effect. The basic reproductive ratio of the epidemic is increased from its individual-to-individual value RG in the absence of local infections to a group-to-group value R* = µRG, where µ is the mean size of an outbreak, started by a randomly chosen individual, in which only local infections count. Where the groups are large and the within-group epidemics are above threshold, this amplification can permit an outbreak in the whole population at very low levels of pG, for instance, for pG = O(1/Nn) in a population of N divided into groups of size n. The implication of these results for control strategies is that vaccination should be directed preferentially toward reducing µ; we discuss the conditions under which the equalizing strategy, aimed at leaving unvaccinated sets of neighbors of equal sizes, is optimal. We also discuss the estimation of our threshold parameter R* from data on epidemics among households.

AB - We consider epidemics with removal (SIR epidemics) in populations that mix at two levels: global and local. We develop a general modelling framework for such processes, which allows us to analyze the conditions under which a large outbreak is possible, the size of such outbreaks when they can occur and the implications for vaccination strategies, in each case comparing our results with the simpler homogeneous mixing case. More precisely, we consider models in which each infectious individual i has a global probability pG for infecting each other individual in the population and a local probability pL, typically much larger, of infecting each other individual among a set of neighbors script N (i). Our main concern is the case where the population is partitioned into local groups or households, but our approach also applies to cases where neighborhoods do not form a partition, for instance, to spatial models with a mixture of local (e.g., nearest-neighbor) and global contacts. We use a variety of theoretical approaches: a random graph framework for the initial exposition of the simple case where an individual's contacts are independent; branching process approximations for the general threshold result; and an embedding representation for rigorous results on the final size of outbreaks. From the applied viewpoint the key result is that, compared with the homogeneous mixing model in which individuals make contacts simply with probability pG, the local infectious contacts have an "amplification" effect. The basic reproductive ratio of the epidemic is increased from its individual-to-individual value RG in the absence of local infections to a group-to-group value R* = µRG, where µ is the mean size of an outbreak, started by a randomly chosen individual, in which only local infections count. Where the groups are large and the within-group epidemics are above threshold, this amplification can permit an outbreak in the whole population at very low levels of pG, for instance, for pG = O(1/Nn) in a population of N divided into groups of size n. The implication of these results for control strategies is that vaccination should be directed preferentially toward reducing µ; we discuss the conditions under which the equalizing strategy, aimed at leaving unvaccinated sets of neighbors of equal sizes, is optimal. We also discuss the estimation of our threshold parameter R* from data on epidemics among households.

KW - Asymptotic distribution

KW - Branching processes

KW - Embedding

KW - Epidemic

KW - Estimation

KW - Final outcome

KW - Gontcharoff polynomials

KW - Household

KW - R 0

KW - Random graphs

KW - Reed-Frost

KW - Threshold parameters

KW - Vaccination

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=0031285152&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Article

VL - 7

SP - 46

EP - 89

JO - Annals of Applied Probability

JF - Annals of Applied Probability

SN - 1050-5164

IS - 1

ER -

Ball F, Mollison D, Scalia-Tomba G. Epidemics with two levels of mixing. Annals of Applied Probability. 1997 Feb;7(1):46-89.