Does egg production represent adult female copepod growth? A call to account for body weight changes

A. G. Hirst, A. D. McKinnon

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    Abstract

    An almost universal assumption in determining growth in copepods is that, over short periods, an individual adult female's net growth is equal to the amount of material expelled as eggs. This assumption relies upon adult body mass being in steady-state between the start and end of the same period. We explore different situations where this assumption is violated. Initially, concepts of how adult body weight and egg output are coupled over time are addressed. Using a refined concept of growth, we show that using typical 24 h incubation methods to measure egg output in sac spawners or broadcasters that produce clutches of eggs with a periodicity of >1 d may give correct mean population growth rates, but erroneous individual rates (including maximum and minimum individual growth, and measurements of individual variability such as coefficient of variation). Measurements derived from laboratory and field studies are then used to explore errors associated with the steady-state assumption. Decoupling of egg production from assimilation, and non-steady-state body weight in large lipid-storing higher-latitude species are relatively well documented, yet growth estimates allowing for such changes have almost never been made. Errors are not limited only to such species, however, and changing adult body weights can occur in small temperate and tropical species too. Body weight can increase or decrease whether or not eggs are exuded over the same period. The errors that can arise if we assume that the output of eggs by females equals their net growth rate are large and variable; in our compilation they range from -208% (i.e. egg output being 9.7% of body carbon weight per day, but adult carbon weight simultaneously declining by 13.7% d-1) to +71% (i.e. egg output being 1.5% of body carbon weight per day, and adult carbon weight simultaneously increasing by 4.3% d-1). Using measurement of the natural variability in adult body weights, we determined that in order to be able to discriminate significant changes in body weight of 1 and 10% respectively, >1000 and <100 replicates are necessary, if applying typical sacrificial weighing methods. If we are to make accurate estimates of growth in adult copepods, then changes in body weight are of fundamental importance. We make initial recommendations for tackling these problems and reducing errors in the future.

    Original languageEnglish
    Pages (from-to)179-199
    Number of pages21
    JournalMarine Ecology Progress Series
    Volume223
    DOIs
    Publication statusPublished - 28 Nov 2001

    Fingerprint

    body weight changes
    egg production
    Copepoda
    body weight
    carbon
    broadcasters
    periodicity
    egg masses
    assimilation (physiology)
    population growth
    lipids
    methodology

    Keywords

    • Body weight
    • Copepod
    • Egg production
    • Net growth

    Cite this

    @article{c9fd0182fd04473ea95f5ad077e74077,
    title = "Does egg production represent adult female copepod growth? A call to account for body weight changes",
    abstract = "An almost universal assumption in determining growth in copepods is that, over short periods, an individual adult female's net growth is equal to the amount of material expelled as eggs. This assumption relies upon adult body mass being in steady-state between the start and end of the same period. We explore different situations where this assumption is violated. Initially, concepts of how adult body weight and egg output are coupled over time are addressed. Using a refined concept of growth, we show that using typical 24 h incubation methods to measure egg output in sac spawners or broadcasters that produce clutches of eggs with a periodicity of >1 d may give correct mean population growth rates, but erroneous individual rates (including maximum and minimum individual growth, and measurements of individual variability such as coefficient of variation). Measurements derived from laboratory and field studies are then used to explore errors associated with the steady-state assumption. Decoupling of egg production from assimilation, and non-steady-state body weight in large lipid-storing higher-latitude species are relatively well documented, yet growth estimates allowing for such changes have almost never been made. Errors are not limited only to such species, however, and changing adult body weights can occur in small temperate and tropical species too. Body weight can increase or decrease whether or not eggs are exuded over the same period. The errors that can arise if we assume that the output of eggs by females equals their net growth rate are large and variable; in our compilation they range from -208{\%} (i.e. egg output being 9.7{\%} of body carbon weight per day, but adult carbon weight simultaneously declining by 13.7{\%} d-1) to +71{\%} (i.e. egg output being 1.5{\%} of body carbon weight per day, and adult carbon weight simultaneously increasing by 4.3{\%} d-1). Using measurement of the natural variability in adult body weights, we determined that in order to be able to discriminate significant changes in body weight of 1 and 10{\%} respectively, >1000 and <100 replicates are necessary, if applying typical sacrificial weighing methods. If we are to make accurate estimates of growth in adult copepods, then changes in body weight are of fundamental importance. We make initial recommendations for tackling these problems and reducing errors in the future.",
    keywords = "Body weight, Copepod, Egg production, Net growth",
    author = "Hirst, {A. G.} and McKinnon, {A. D.}",
    year = "2001",
    month = "11",
    day = "28",
    doi = "10.3354/meps223179",
    language = "English",
    volume = "223",
    pages = "179--199",
    journal = "Marine Ecology Progress Series",
    issn = "0171-8630",
    publisher = "Inter-Research",

    }

    Does egg production represent adult female copepod growth? A call to account for body weight changes. / Hirst, A. G.; McKinnon, A. D.

    In: Marine Ecology Progress Series, Vol. 223, 28.11.2001, p. 179-199.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    TY - JOUR

    T1 - Does egg production represent adult female copepod growth? A call to account for body weight changes

    AU - Hirst, A. G.

    AU - McKinnon, A. D.

    PY - 2001/11/28

    Y1 - 2001/11/28

    N2 - An almost universal assumption in determining growth in copepods is that, over short periods, an individual adult female's net growth is equal to the amount of material expelled as eggs. This assumption relies upon adult body mass being in steady-state between the start and end of the same period. We explore different situations where this assumption is violated. Initially, concepts of how adult body weight and egg output are coupled over time are addressed. Using a refined concept of growth, we show that using typical 24 h incubation methods to measure egg output in sac spawners or broadcasters that produce clutches of eggs with a periodicity of >1 d may give correct mean population growth rates, but erroneous individual rates (including maximum and minimum individual growth, and measurements of individual variability such as coefficient of variation). Measurements derived from laboratory and field studies are then used to explore errors associated with the steady-state assumption. Decoupling of egg production from assimilation, and non-steady-state body weight in large lipid-storing higher-latitude species are relatively well documented, yet growth estimates allowing for such changes have almost never been made. Errors are not limited only to such species, however, and changing adult body weights can occur in small temperate and tropical species too. Body weight can increase or decrease whether or not eggs are exuded over the same period. The errors that can arise if we assume that the output of eggs by females equals their net growth rate are large and variable; in our compilation they range from -208% (i.e. egg output being 9.7% of body carbon weight per day, but adult carbon weight simultaneously declining by 13.7% d-1) to +71% (i.e. egg output being 1.5% of body carbon weight per day, and adult carbon weight simultaneously increasing by 4.3% d-1). Using measurement of the natural variability in adult body weights, we determined that in order to be able to discriminate significant changes in body weight of 1 and 10% respectively, >1000 and <100 replicates are necessary, if applying typical sacrificial weighing methods. If we are to make accurate estimates of growth in adult copepods, then changes in body weight are of fundamental importance. We make initial recommendations for tackling these problems and reducing errors in the future.

    AB - An almost universal assumption in determining growth in copepods is that, over short periods, an individual adult female's net growth is equal to the amount of material expelled as eggs. This assumption relies upon adult body mass being in steady-state between the start and end of the same period. We explore different situations where this assumption is violated. Initially, concepts of how adult body weight and egg output are coupled over time are addressed. Using a refined concept of growth, we show that using typical 24 h incubation methods to measure egg output in sac spawners or broadcasters that produce clutches of eggs with a periodicity of >1 d may give correct mean population growth rates, but erroneous individual rates (including maximum and minimum individual growth, and measurements of individual variability such as coefficient of variation). Measurements derived from laboratory and field studies are then used to explore errors associated with the steady-state assumption. Decoupling of egg production from assimilation, and non-steady-state body weight in large lipid-storing higher-latitude species are relatively well documented, yet growth estimates allowing for such changes have almost never been made. Errors are not limited only to such species, however, and changing adult body weights can occur in small temperate and tropical species too. Body weight can increase or decrease whether or not eggs are exuded over the same period. The errors that can arise if we assume that the output of eggs by females equals their net growth rate are large and variable; in our compilation they range from -208% (i.e. egg output being 9.7% of body carbon weight per day, but adult carbon weight simultaneously declining by 13.7% d-1) to +71% (i.e. egg output being 1.5% of body carbon weight per day, and adult carbon weight simultaneously increasing by 4.3% d-1). Using measurement of the natural variability in adult body weights, we determined that in order to be able to discriminate significant changes in body weight of 1 and 10% respectively, >1000 and <100 replicates are necessary, if applying typical sacrificial weighing methods. If we are to make accurate estimates of growth in adult copepods, then changes in body weight are of fundamental importance. We make initial recommendations for tackling these problems and reducing errors in the future.

    KW - Body weight

    KW - Copepod

    KW - Egg production

    KW - Net growth

    UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=0035965864&partnerID=8YFLogxK

    U2 - 10.3354/meps223179

    DO - 10.3354/meps223179

    M3 - Article

    VL - 223

    SP - 179

    EP - 199

    JO - Marine Ecology Progress Series

    JF - Marine Ecology Progress Series

    SN - 0171-8630

    ER -