Community Perceptions of Local Knowledge for Community-Based Flood Risk Management: The Case of ‘Zamakolo’ in Malawi

Robert Sakic Trogrlic, Grant Wright, Adebayo Adeloye, Melanie J. Duncan, Faidess Dumbizgani Mwale

Research output: Contribution to conferencePaper

Abstract

In the developing world, community-based disaster risk reduction (CB-DRR) presents a well-established approach for reducing vulnerabilities of rural communities. CB-DRR interventions have emerged as a way to foster community participation, create empowerment and integrate local perspectives. The premise that local knowledge (LK) constitutes an important determinant of community resilience to disasters has been increasingly promoted in scholarly work and international policy arenas. However, despite the ‘promise of inclusion’ of CB-DRR, realities from the ground imply that participation, and consequently, inclusion of LK, is often limited. In addition, existing literature is largely focused on the documentation of LK, without a deeper understanding of how communities, as creators, holders and users of this knowledge perceive its’ usefulness for disaster risk reduction. This paper explores the realities of LK in community-based flood risk management (CB-FRM) in the Lower Shire Valley, the
most vulnerable region affected by annual flooding in Malawi. Through a thematic analysis of a series of focus group discussions, key informant interviews and field visits in 12 rural communities (conducted April 2016-September 2017), the study explores the prominence of LK in existing approaches for dealing with flood risk. The results indicate a vast array of methods, embedded in the local tradition, understandable by community members and not requiring any formal educational or external support. However, participants also reported a perceived decrease in the role of LK, driven primarily by climate change and environmental degradation, which threatens its’ future use. Accordingly, participants expressed a general preference towards the type of “modern” CB-FRM approaches, introduced by external organisations, that do not explicitly integrate LK. Overall, experiences from Malawi suggest the need for a system for documenting and preserving LK, better integration of LK into the work of development partners, and finally, rethinking how communities’ confidence into their own capacities
could be increased.
Original languageEnglish
Publication statusPublished - 17 Jul 2018
EventXIX ISA World Congress of Sociology - Toronto, Canada
Duration: 15 Jul 201821 Jul 2018

Conference

ConferenceXIX ISA World Congress of Sociology
CountryCanada
CityToronto
Period15/07/1821/07/18

Fingerprint

traditional knowledge
disaster
risk management
local participation
empowerment
environmental degradation
vulnerability
flooding
developing world
valley
climate change
risk reduction

Cite this

Sakic Trogrlic, R., Wright, G., Adeloye, A., Duncan, M. J., & Mwale, F. D. (2018). Community Perceptions of Local Knowledge for Community-Based Flood Risk Management: The Case of ‘Zamakolo’ in Malawi. Paper presented at XIX ISA World Congress of Sociology, Toronto, Canada.
Sakic Trogrlic, Robert ; Wright, Grant ; Adeloye, Adebayo ; Duncan, Melanie J. ; Mwale, Faidess Dumbizgani. / Community Perceptions of Local Knowledge for Community-Based Flood Risk Management: The Case of ‘Zamakolo’ in Malawi. Paper presented at XIX ISA World Congress of Sociology, Toronto, Canada.
@conference{24952e8f07f741f9982561b0558b96cd,
title = "Community Perceptions of Local Knowledge for Community-Based Flood Risk Management: The Case of ‘Zamakolo’ in Malawi",
abstract = "In the developing world, community-based disaster risk reduction (CB-DRR) presents a well-established approach for reducing vulnerabilities of rural communities. CB-DRR interventions have emerged as a way to foster community participation, create empowerment and integrate local perspectives. The premise that local knowledge (LK) constitutes an important determinant of community resilience to disasters has been increasingly promoted in scholarly work and international policy arenas. However, despite the ‘promise of inclusion’ of CB-DRR, realities from the ground imply that participation, and consequently, inclusion of LK, is often limited. In addition, existing literature is largely focused on the documentation of LK, without a deeper understanding of how communities, as creators, holders and users of this knowledge perceive its’ usefulness for disaster risk reduction. This paper explores the realities of LK in community-based flood risk management (CB-FRM) in the Lower Shire Valley, themost vulnerable region affected by annual flooding in Malawi. Through a thematic analysis of a series of focus group discussions, key informant interviews and field visits in 12 rural communities (conducted April 2016-September 2017), the study explores the prominence of LK in existing approaches for dealing with flood risk. The results indicate a vast array of methods, embedded in the local tradition, understandable by community members and not requiring any formal educational or external support. However, participants also reported a perceived decrease in the role of LK, driven primarily by climate change and environmental degradation, which threatens its’ future use. Accordingly, participants expressed a general preference towards the type of “modern” CB-FRM approaches, introduced by external organisations, that do not explicitly integrate LK. Overall, experiences from Malawi suggest the need for a system for documenting and preserving LK, better integration of LK into the work of development partners, and finally, rethinking how communities’ confidence into their own capacitiescould be increased.",
author = "{Sakic Trogrlic}, Robert and Grant Wright and Adebayo Adeloye and Duncan, {Melanie J.} and Mwale, {Faidess Dumbizgani}",
year = "2018",
month = "7",
day = "17",
language = "English",
note = "XIX ISA World Congress of Sociology ; Conference date: 15-07-2018 Through 21-07-2018",

}

Sakic Trogrlic, R, Wright, G, Adeloye, A, Duncan, MJ & Mwale, FD 2018, 'Community Perceptions of Local Knowledge for Community-Based Flood Risk Management: The Case of ‘Zamakolo’ in Malawi' Paper presented at XIX ISA World Congress of Sociology, Toronto, Canada, 15/07/18 - 21/07/18, .

Community Perceptions of Local Knowledge for Community-Based Flood Risk Management: The Case of ‘Zamakolo’ in Malawi. / Sakic Trogrlic, Robert; Wright, Grant; Adeloye, Adebayo; Duncan, Melanie J.; Mwale, Faidess Dumbizgani.

2018. Paper presented at XIX ISA World Congress of Sociology, Toronto, Canada.

Research output: Contribution to conferencePaper

TY - CONF

T1 - Community Perceptions of Local Knowledge for Community-Based Flood Risk Management: The Case of ‘Zamakolo’ in Malawi

AU - Sakic Trogrlic, Robert

AU - Wright, Grant

AU - Adeloye, Adebayo

AU - Duncan, Melanie J.

AU - Mwale, Faidess Dumbizgani

PY - 2018/7/17

Y1 - 2018/7/17

N2 - In the developing world, community-based disaster risk reduction (CB-DRR) presents a well-established approach for reducing vulnerabilities of rural communities. CB-DRR interventions have emerged as a way to foster community participation, create empowerment and integrate local perspectives. The premise that local knowledge (LK) constitutes an important determinant of community resilience to disasters has been increasingly promoted in scholarly work and international policy arenas. However, despite the ‘promise of inclusion’ of CB-DRR, realities from the ground imply that participation, and consequently, inclusion of LK, is often limited. In addition, existing literature is largely focused on the documentation of LK, without a deeper understanding of how communities, as creators, holders and users of this knowledge perceive its’ usefulness for disaster risk reduction. This paper explores the realities of LK in community-based flood risk management (CB-FRM) in the Lower Shire Valley, themost vulnerable region affected by annual flooding in Malawi. Through a thematic analysis of a series of focus group discussions, key informant interviews and field visits in 12 rural communities (conducted April 2016-September 2017), the study explores the prominence of LK in existing approaches for dealing with flood risk. The results indicate a vast array of methods, embedded in the local tradition, understandable by community members and not requiring any formal educational or external support. However, participants also reported a perceived decrease in the role of LK, driven primarily by climate change and environmental degradation, which threatens its’ future use. Accordingly, participants expressed a general preference towards the type of “modern” CB-FRM approaches, introduced by external organisations, that do not explicitly integrate LK. Overall, experiences from Malawi suggest the need for a system for documenting and preserving LK, better integration of LK into the work of development partners, and finally, rethinking how communities’ confidence into their own capacitiescould be increased.

AB - In the developing world, community-based disaster risk reduction (CB-DRR) presents a well-established approach for reducing vulnerabilities of rural communities. CB-DRR interventions have emerged as a way to foster community participation, create empowerment and integrate local perspectives. The premise that local knowledge (LK) constitutes an important determinant of community resilience to disasters has been increasingly promoted in scholarly work and international policy arenas. However, despite the ‘promise of inclusion’ of CB-DRR, realities from the ground imply that participation, and consequently, inclusion of LK, is often limited. In addition, existing literature is largely focused on the documentation of LK, without a deeper understanding of how communities, as creators, holders and users of this knowledge perceive its’ usefulness for disaster risk reduction. This paper explores the realities of LK in community-based flood risk management (CB-FRM) in the Lower Shire Valley, themost vulnerable region affected by annual flooding in Malawi. Through a thematic analysis of a series of focus group discussions, key informant interviews and field visits in 12 rural communities (conducted April 2016-September 2017), the study explores the prominence of LK in existing approaches for dealing with flood risk. The results indicate a vast array of methods, embedded in the local tradition, understandable by community members and not requiring any formal educational or external support. However, participants also reported a perceived decrease in the role of LK, driven primarily by climate change and environmental degradation, which threatens its’ future use. Accordingly, participants expressed a general preference towards the type of “modern” CB-FRM approaches, introduced by external organisations, that do not explicitly integrate LK. Overall, experiences from Malawi suggest the need for a system for documenting and preserving LK, better integration of LK into the work of development partners, and finally, rethinking how communities’ confidence into their own capacitiescould be increased.

M3 - Paper

ER -

Sakic Trogrlic R, Wright G, Adeloye A, Duncan MJ, Mwale FD. Community Perceptions of Local Knowledge for Community-Based Flood Risk Management: The Case of ‘Zamakolo’ in Malawi. 2018. Paper presented at XIX ISA World Congress of Sociology, Toronto, Canada.