A tool for protected area management: multivariate control charts ‘cope’ with rare variable communities

Thomas Stringell, Roger Bamber, Mark Burton, Charles Lindenbaum, Skates Lucie, William Sanderson

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    Abstract

    1. Performance assessment, impact detection and the assessment of regulatory compliance are common scientific problems for the management of protected areas. Some habitats in protected areas, however, are rare and/or variable and are not often selected for study by ecologists because they preclude comparison with controls and high community variability makes meaningful change detection difficult.
    2. Low volume coastal saline lagoons are habitats that experience comparatively high levels of stress due to high physical variability. Lagoons are rare, declining habitats found in coastal regions throughout Europe where they are identified as one of the habitats most in need of protected area management.
    3. The macroscopic infauna in the sediments of 26 coastal saline lagoons were sampled, sieved and enumerated. Temporal and spatial variation in three of these [protected] lagoon communities was investigated further over five years.
    4. In a multivariate analysis of community structure similarities were found between some lagoons but in other cases communities were unique or specific to only two sites. The protected lagoons with these unique/specific communities showed significant temporal and spatial variation, yet none of the changes observed were attributed to anthropogenic impacts and were interpreted as inherent variability.
    5. The aim of control chart analysis is to characterise background variability in a parameter and identify when a new observation deviates more than expected. Multivariate control charts can operate without experimental controls and were used to assess community changes within the context of ‘normal’ variability. In only one year were changes genuinely ‘unusual’ and corresponded with the coldest December in over 100 years.
    6. Synthesis and applications: Multivariate control charts are likely to have wide application in the management of protected areas and other natural systems where variability and/or rarity preclude conventional analytical and experimental approaches but where assessments of condition, impact or regulatory compliance are nonetheless required.
    Original languageEnglish
    Pages (from-to)1-10
    JournalEcology and Evolution
    Volume3
    Issue number6
    Early online date1 May 2013
    DOIs
    Publication statusPublished - 2013

    Fingerprint

    Ecosystem
    Compliance
    Multivariate Analysis
    Observation

    Keywords

    • Conservation management
    • Habitats Directive
    • Water Framework Directive
    • sustainable use
    • indicator
    • lagoon

    Cite this

    Stringell, Thomas ; Bamber, Roger ; Burton, Mark ; Lindenbaum, Charles ; Lucie, Skates ; Sanderson, William. / A tool for protected area management: multivariate control charts ‘cope’ with rare variable communities. In: Ecology and Evolution. 2013 ; Vol. 3, No. 6. pp. 1-10.
    @article{b140fbd2e9834cdcb6f3e8bbbc31171a,
    title = "A tool for protected area management: multivariate control charts ‘cope’ with rare variable communities",
    abstract = "1. Performance assessment, impact detection and the assessment of regulatory compliance are common scientific problems for the management of protected areas. Some habitats in protected areas, however, are rare and/or variable and are not often selected for study by ecologists because they preclude comparison with controls and high community variability makes meaningful change detection difficult. 2. Low volume coastal saline lagoons are habitats that experience comparatively high levels of stress due to high physical variability. Lagoons are rare, declining habitats found in coastal regions throughout Europe where they are identified as one of the habitats most in need of protected area management. 3. The macroscopic infauna in the sediments of 26 coastal saline lagoons were sampled, sieved and enumerated. Temporal and spatial variation in three of these [protected] lagoon communities was investigated further over five years. 4. In a multivariate analysis of community structure similarities were found between some lagoons but in other cases communities were unique or specific to only two sites. The protected lagoons with these unique/specific communities showed significant temporal and spatial variation, yet none of the changes observed were attributed to anthropogenic impacts and were interpreted as inherent variability. 5. The aim of control chart analysis is to characterise background variability in a parameter and identify when a new observation deviates more than expected. Multivariate control charts can operate without experimental controls and were used to assess community changes within the context of ‘normal’ variability. In only one year were changes genuinely ‘unusual’ and corresponded with the coldest December in over 100 years. 6. Synthesis and applications: Multivariate control charts are likely to have wide application in the management of protected areas and other natural systems where variability and/or rarity preclude conventional analytical and experimental approaches but where assessments of condition, impact or regulatory compliance are nonetheless required.",
    keywords = "Conservation management, Habitats Directive, Water Framework Directive , sustainable use, indicator, lagoon",
    author = "Thomas Stringell and Roger Bamber and Mark Burton and Charles Lindenbaum and Skates Lucie and William Sanderson",
    note = "JEE has been accepted for indexing by the Institute for Scientific Information (ISI) in Current Contents/Agriculture, Biology & Environmental Sciences, the Journal Citation Report, and Science Citation Index Expanded with coverage to begin from volume 1 issue 1. Ecology and Evolution should receive its first Impact Factor in 2013.",
    year = "2013",
    doi = "10.1002/ece3.585",
    language = "English",
    volume = "3",
    pages = "1--10",
    journal = "Ecology and Evolution",
    issn = "2045-7758",
    publisher = "John Wiley and Sons Ltd",
    number = "6",

    }

    A tool for protected area management: multivariate control charts ‘cope’ with rare variable communities. / Stringell, Thomas; Bamber, Roger; Burton, Mark; Lindenbaum, Charles; Lucie, Skates; Sanderson, William.

    In: Ecology and Evolution, Vol. 3, No. 6, 2013, p. 1-10.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    TY - JOUR

    T1 - A tool for protected area management: multivariate control charts ‘cope’ with rare variable communities

    AU - Stringell, Thomas

    AU - Bamber, Roger

    AU - Burton, Mark

    AU - Lindenbaum, Charles

    AU - Lucie, Skates

    AU - Sanderson, William

    N1 - JEE has been accepted for indexing by the Institute for Scientific Information (ISI) in Current Contents/Agriculture, Biology & Environmental Sciences, the Journal Citation Report, and Science Citation Index Expanded with coverage to begin from volume 1 issue 1. Ecology and Evolution should receive its first Impact Factor in 2013.

    PY - 2013

    Y1 - 2013

    N2 - 1. Performance assessment, impact detection and the assessment of regulatory compliance are common scientific problems for the management of protected areas. Some habitats in protected areas, however, are rare and/or variable and are not often selected for study by ecologists because they preclude comparison with controls and high community variability makes meaningful change detection difficult. 2. Low volume coastal saline lagoons are habitats that experience comparatively high levels of stress due to high physical variability. Lagoons are rare, declining habitats found in coastal regions throughout Europe where they are identified as one of the habitats most in need of protected area management. 3. The macroscopic infauna in the sediments of 26 coastal saline lagoons were sampled, sieved and enumerated. Temporal and spatial variation in three of these [protected] lagoon communities was investigated further over five years. 4. In a multivariate analysis of community structure similarities were found between some lagoons but in other cases communities were unique or specific to only two sites. The protected lagoons with these unique/specific communities showed significant temporal and spatial variation, yet none of the changes observed were attributed to anthropogenic impacts and were interpreted as inherent variability. 5. The aim of control chart analysis is to characterise background variability in a parameter and identify when a new observation deviates more than expected. Multivariate control charts can operate without experimental controls and were used to assess community changes within the context of ‘normal’ variability. In only one year were changes genuinely ‘unusual’ and corresponded with the coldest December in over 100 years. 6. Synthesis and applications: Multivariate control charts are likely to have wide application in the management of protected areas and other natural systems where variability and/or rarity preclude conventional analytical and experimental approaches but where assessments of condition, impact or regulatory compliance are nonetheless required.

    AB - 1. Performance assessment, impact detection and the assessment of regulatory compliance are common scientific problems for the management of protected areas. Some habitats in protected areas, however, are rare and/or variable and are not often selected for study by ecologists because they preclude comparison with controls and high community variability makes meaningful change detection difficult. 2. Low volume coastal saline lagoons are habitats that experience comparatively high levels of stress due to high physical variability. Lagoons are rare, declining habitats found in coastal regions throughout Europe where they are identified as one of the habitats most in need of protected area management. 3. The macroscopic infauna in the sediments of 26 coastal saline lagoons were sampled, sieved and enumerated. Temporal and spatial variation in three of these [protected] lagoon communities was investigated further over five years. 4. In a multivariate analysis of community structure similarities were found between some lagoons but in other cases communities were unique or specific to only two sites. The protected lagoons with these unique/specific communities showed significant temporal and spatial variation, yet none of the changes observed were attributed to anthropogenic impacts and were interpreted as inherent variability. 5. The aim of control chart analysis is to characterise background variability in a parameter and identify when a new observation deviates more than expected. Multivariate control charts can operate without experimental controls and were used to assess community changes within the context of ‘normal’ variability. In only one year were changes genuinely ‘unusual’ and corresponded with the coldest December in over 100 years. 6. Synthesis and applications: Multivariate control charts are likely to have wide application in the management of protected areas and other natural systems where variability and/or rarity preclude conventional analytical and experimental approaches but where assessments of condition, impact or regulatory compliance are nonetheless required.

    KW - Conservation management

    KW - Habitats Directive

    KW - Water Framework Directive

    KW - sustainable use

    KW - indicator

    KW - lagoon

    U2 - 10.1002/ece3.585

    DO - 10.1002/ece3.585

    M3 - Article

    C2 - 23789076

    VL - 3

    SP - 1

    EP - 10

    JO - Ecology and Evolution

    JF - Ecology and Evolution

    SN - 2045-7758

    IS - 6

    ER -